Enter Into Joy

Sunday, December 12, 2010

Are rocks alive?


Crystal Skeleton by Lawrence Stoller

Look closely at a grain of sand, the seed of a thousand beings can be seen. 
Mahmud Shabestari14th century.

The recent discovery, by NASA scientists, of so-called “arsenic-based microbes” may have redefined life as we know it. Certainly there are places inhabited by life that we haven’t found yet. And the line between animate and inanimate isn’t sharply drawn.

A common thread of the mystical experience is the realization of the unity of life. How does the Mineral Kingdom fit into the picture? In the Bible, and in the Koran, God created Adam from clay, and breathed life into him.

The earliest fossils known, microbial remains, are about 3.8 billion years old. The origin of those early, simple life-forms is a matter of debate. There are several theories, one being that mineral crystals formed a kind of template for organic molecules.

Scottish biochemist Graham Cairns-Smith developed a theory of “genetic takeover”. The precursor to biological life may have been tiny, platy, crystals of a clay mineral, like kaolinite, which actually grows and replicates itself when in the right environment.

Wind picks up the tiny crystals as dust, and scatters them to new places. The flat faces of the crystals are templates for identical crystals to form – replicates. The surfaces carry information - a kind of genetic code. They have a regular, repeated arrangement of charged atoms that also can attract and organize simple organic compounds, and act as a catalyst for chemical reactions.
Perhaps the reactions formed an organic coating to protect the crystals from weathering. These arrangements of organic molecules may have eventually become RNA and DNA. Eventually, the coatings themselves began replicating, and these primitive biological replicators took over from the geological ones.
In addition to growing, and replicating themselves, minerals have evolved along with plants and animals. About two-thirds of the more than 4,000 known mineral species are linked to bioligical activity, mainly because of the development of an oxygen-rich atmosphere that is a consequence of photosynthesis.
 
For the vast majority of human history, the Stone Age, the working of flint for arrowheads was the pinnacle of technology. Now, some think that life may be approaching another genetic takeover – by self-sufficient, self-replicating, machines.  An inorganic machine of this type could be more efficient than an animal. The information-carrying part of most advanced machines is the integrated circuit – a man-made crystal. So, while rocks may not be alive in the conventional sense, biological life may be bookended by crystals.

 “Dust Thou Art, and Unto Dust Shalt Thou Return. “ (Genesis 2:7).
— Kelly Nash

1 comments:

Anonymous said...

i've always been fascinated to learn that the Hemoglobin molecule closely resembles the structural configuration of a Chlorophyll molecule, except the former has an Iron atom at its core, and Chlorophyll has Magnesium at its core. [ what follows was adapted by an AI inquiry mode ]:
Those molecules function as vital carriers: Hemoglobin carries Oxygen atoms during Respiration, and Chlorophyll carries Energy during Photosynthesis--complementary and reciprocal processes that are essential to life on the planet.

They are both built upon a "porphyrin ring," a complex circular structure that acts as a scaffold for holding a single metal atom; and feature a "head" made of four small nitrogen-containing rings (pyrrole rings) linked together in a larger circle. They differ in that, Hemoglobin contains an Iron (Fe) atom, which is essential for binding and transporting oxygen in the blood, while Chlorophyll contains a Magnesium (Mg) atom, which is optimized for capturing light energy during photosynthesis.

This ring structure is incredibly stable and highly effective at managing energy and electrons, making it perfect for both moving gases (oxygen) and harvesting sunlight. Both molecules share ancient biosynthetic precursors, such as "protoporphyrin IX." This suggests they likely evolved from a common "toolbox" of molecules used by early life forms. Both are designed to "carry" something vital for life—Hemoglobin carries oxygen to keep cells alive, and Chlorophyll carries the energy from photons of light to create food by converting carbon dioxide and water into complex sugars.

Chlorophyll acts like a solar panel. In the chloroplast of the plant cell, it captures light energy and converts it into "electrical" energy (excited electrons). This energy is then used to create two high-energy "power packs": ATP and NADPH. The molecule that actually "catches" CO₂ is an enzyme which then attaches it to a 5-carbon sugar, using that energy which Chlorophyll just collected from the Sun. Thus, Chlorophyll provides the gas money (energy), but the specific Enzyme is the delivery truck that actually handles the CO₂.

Cellular Respiration harvests the Energy stored in the sugars of the food you eat by a series of complex chemical reactions in the Mitochondria of your cells.

Chemical Equation for Photosynthesis, which Stores Energy in high-energy carbon bonds:

6CO₂ + 6H₂O + Light → C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6O₆

Respiration, which Releases Energy by breaking those chemical bonds:

C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6O₆ → 6CO₂ + 6H₂O + ATP

Think of it like a rechargeable battery:
Photosynthesis is the charger: and takes low-energy molecules (CO₂ and H₂O) and employs solar power to "charge" them into high-energy molecules (glucose), while emitting oxygen.

Respiration withdraws from the battery as it drains (oxidizes, with every breath) the glucose to do work, leaving behind the low-energy "empty" molecules (CO₂ and H₂O) to be charged again by plants.

They are "Complementary" and interdependent processes of the Carbon Cycle.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - -

As for the "arsenic-based microbes," it remains to be verified: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/arsenic-life-microbe-study-retracted-after-15-years-of-controversy/

https://retractionwatch.com/2025/07/24/science-retraction-arsenic-life-nasa-astrobiology/#:~:text=Science%20has%20retracted%20a%202010,reflect%20best%20practices%20for%20publishers.

Post a Comment